Why pictures and drawing help people learn: what the research says
By the Sketchwise team ·
Studies of how people learn from words and pictures point to a few dependable findings: words with a relevant picture are usually remembered better than words alone, spoken words beside a picture are easier to follow than printed text over it, and drawing something yourself helps you remember it. Here is what each finding says, and where it stops.
Two kinds of memory for one idea
Allan Paivio's dual coding theory proposes that the mind keeps words and images in two related systems. An idea held both ways has two routes back to it. This is one explanation for a common observation: a concrete word with an image ("volcano") is easier to recall than an abstract one with none.
Words and pictures together
Richard Mayer and colleagues ran many experiments comparing lessons made of words alone with the same words plus a picture. Learners given both usually did better on tests of understanding, not only of recall. Mayer calls this the multimedia principle.
The same body of work found conditions under which the benefit holds:
- The picture must be relevant. Decorative images and extra detail tend to hurt (the coherence principle).
- Words are better spoken than printed when they accompany an animation or diagram, so the eyes can stay on the picture (the modality principle).
- A label belongs next to the part it names, not in a key at the side (the spatial contiguity principle).
- Spoken words should come at the same time as the part they describe, not before or after (the temporal contiguity principle).
- Breaking a complex explanation into learner-paced segments helps beginners (the segmenting principle).
Drawing it yourself
Separate studies looked at the learner doing the drawing. Wammes, Meade and Fernandes found that people asked to draw a word remembered it better than people asked to write it out, a result they called the drawing effect. Fiorella and Mayer list learning by drawing among eight generative learning strategies: activities in which the learner makes something from what they are learning, which tends to deepen understanding.
Watching a drawing appear is not the same as drawing. A good use of a drawn explanation is to watch it, then close it and sketch it again from memory.
Where the findings stop
These are average effects from controlled studies, mostly with students in a laboratory or classroom setting. The size of the benefit varies with the learner, the subject and how well the picture is made. A poor diagram can teach less than a clear paragraph. And learning styles, the idea that each person learns best through one sense, is a different claim: reviews of the evidence have not supported matching teaching to a supposed style. Pictures help most people, for the reasons above, not only "visual learners".
What this means for an explanation
- Use a picture that shows the idea, not one that decorates the page.
- Speak the explanation beside the picture rather than printing paragraphs on it.
- Put each label on the part it names, at the moment it is explained.
- Show the steps one at a time.
- Then ask the learner to draw it themselves.
Sketchwise is built around the first four: it draws an answer part by part, labels each part where it appears, and speaks the explanation as it draws. The fifth is up to the learner.
See it drawn
Ask your own question and watch it drawn and explained. 10 videos free, no card.
Try SketchwiseSources
- Paivio, A. (1971). Imagery and Verbal Processes. Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
- Mayer, R. E. (2021). Multimedia Learning (3rd ed.). Cambridge University Press.
- Fiorella, L., & Mayer, R. E. (2016). Eight ways to promote generative learning. Educational Psychology Review, 28(4), 717 to 741.
- Wammes, J. D., Meade, M. E., & Fernandes, M. A. (2016). The drawing effect: Evidence for reliable and robust memory benefits in free recall. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 69(9), 1752 to 1776.
- Pashler, H., McDaniel, M., Rohrer, D., & Bjork, R. (2008). Learning styles: Concepts and evidence. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 9(3), 105 to 119.
More guides
- How to start a faceless YouTube channel with animated explainer videos
- Ways to earn from animated explainer videos, without showing your face
- 20 faceless channel ideas that suit drawn explainer videos
- How to explain any concept visually, step by step
- Which diagram should you draw? Matching the picture to the question
- How to make a whiteboard-style explainer video for a lesson
- Explaining in your students' own language: why it helps and how to do it